Saturday, August 22, 2009

Top 20 Craziest Things On Record During My Ongoing Custody Battle

1. "The (psychological) testing stated that she (DBE) had the attitude of being very healthy when she is in fact very ill." -Ron Miciotto, attorney for my son's father (Charles H. "Pete" Kammer, III, who is also an attorney), Sept. 4, 2008

2. "Deborah Lynn Buchanan Engles (sic) has no right to litigate these orders." -Ron Miciotto, Aug. 20, 2008.

3. "Debbie became highly agitated, very emotionally labile, argumentative, and absolutely fragmented...she demonstrated no insight into her behaviors and projected blame onto others....and ran out of the office crying loudly....exhibited severe emotional liability (sic) in the session, ranging from sarcasm, anger, sadness, anxiety, calmness to hostility. She was unable to fully process the issues...Debbie had a very hard time taking responsibility for her own actions." - Shelley Booker, LCSW, June 3, 2006

4. "Pete and Stacey Kammer made no disparaging remarks about Debbie..." -Shelley Booker, LCSW, June 3, 2006

5. After I opposed being ordered to pay thousands of dollars for cosmetic orthodontics for my son: "...Orthodontia care, or however you say it, is a part of what is the standard bunch of stuff that a kid is supposed to have. And people that challenge it do so...they run out and they claim it's for cosmetic purposes only....normally they're just people that want to litigate for sport...he (the father) has the right to implement all of this...it's not major medical, it's not an emergency...I'm assuming that you would agree with that...That's why I jumped past all the stuff that just really doesn't matter. Are you with me on that?...It's routine medical care that is engineered into our law by the legislature. Why haven't you paid?" - Judge Woody Nesbitt, June 23, 2006

6. Judge Nesbitt: "I don't have time to read all the reports...and because of the problem of the suit record not being locatable...We can't find your suit record. We have no idea. It's been around. We just can't find it....Is this at the warehouse?"

Clerk: "We've called several times and they said it was checked out to you."

Judge Nesbitt: "It was. It was but don't ask me, I've looked high and low. I thought it was being kept in my office...."

Clerk: "It's probably buried somewhere in your office."

Judge Nesbitt: "What color is it? Does anybody know the color of the file?" -June 23, 2006

7. "She (Shelley Booker) has recommended basically that the Court take immediate steps to essentially seclude, to remove the child from your, if you will, emotional outbursts....I've received hundreds of reports from Ms. Booker and they're usually factually extremely accurate. Sometimes I go with it, sometimes I go opposite. I do commitments monthly....and I have done massive amounts of reading on my own....but all of this is strongly suggestive of very serious what are called personality disorders being onboard with you. You're not being railroaded." -Judge Woody Nesbitt, June 23, 2006

8. Me: "Can I say some words in my own defense?"

Judge: "I'm sorry....you need to just drop it...(Ms. Booker) doesn't make this stuff up....you're going to have to get a grip on the problems that may be onboard. I'm not a diagnosing physician but I tend to be pretty accurate...you do not have the capacity because you just don't understand it and accept it...your kid is an emotional wreck. I'm not going to have your kid testify. I'm not going to talk to him....the road you're on is to be visiting with your child through a plexiglass wall with a court-ordered supervisor at your side at every visitation. I hope you don't have a diagnosed problem called borderline disorder....I'll let (DBE) read it (DBE's defense statement), but I may not give it any weight."

Following that, Judge Nesbitt never let me defend myself, he excused all my witnesses from the courtroom, and never let them return. He stated: "I don't give a hoot who these people are or what they're going to say." -June 23, 2006

9. Me: "Is there no way that we can get an objective party (to act as a mental health/custody expert)?...(Mr. Kammer) had his attorney call me and ask me (to agree to use Shelley Booker, his neighbor & personal friend, as our custody-visitation evaluator)...."

Judge Nesbitt (interrupting): Hang on. Hang on. He didn't pick anybody. You've got to dismiss that. Never happened....He did not have anything to do with Ms. Booker at all...he didn't pick Ms. Booker."

Me: "So if there was only one other alternative (evaluator, according to Judge Nesbitt) besides Ms. (Sandi) Davis then why did he have his attorney call me and ask if I would agree to use Booker?"

Judge Nesbitt: "I don't think that's quite how it happened. I appointed Ms. Booker."

Me: "I'm under oath. Why would I lie?"

Judge Nesbitt: "I'm not worried about it. It's not an issue. Stop creating fictional issues. That is one of the typical personality traits of people with the borderline problem and other personality disorders." -June 23, 2006

10. "I'm going to ask Mr. Miciotto, Mr. Kammer to confer and I'm going to let Mr. Miciotto tell me, recommend, suggest to me something that would be acceptable as recommending and asking that I do in terms of modifying the visitation....I'm going to take Mr. Miciotto and Mr. Kammer up on their offer and since they offered it, I think that is the appropriate interim order." - Judge Woody Nesbitt, June 23, 2006

11. Me: "Do you know that I was - in 2003 (& 2004), I was a court-mandated child abuse reporter? She (Shelley Booker) left that out of her report. I worked for the...."

Judge Nesbitt (interrupting): "We're talking right now." -June 23, 2006

12. Me: "Can I respond to this (Shelley Booker's report)?

Judge: "Yes, go ahead."

Me: "What she did not report was that while I was in the office for about 15 minutes with Joseph in front of Ms. Booker that we talked about some behavioral issues that he had been having at school with his conduct, we talked about the fact that none of this was Joseph's fault that we were going through all this stuff (custody suits filed by Mr. Kammer) that we've had to go through for so many years. We talked about a lot of different things. I patted Joseph on the shoulder, I was nurturing with him, he looked at me and we laughed a couple of times about some things. I mean she put one thing in here and she left out everything else from the whole visit."

Judge Nesbitt: "....you're arguing - you're arguing a pointless point."

Me: "That she excluded important information?"

Judge Nesbitt: "Ma'am, you can find something that has not been input in anyone's report..." -June 23, 2006

13. Me: "(Mr. Kammer) has been suing me for 10 years. He sued me because I had a pond on my property. He filed a motion against me...in 2004 alleging that I owed Joseph's school over $8,000 and dropped it (the lawsuit) within the next few days. I mean he just has a pattern of doing this to me, harassing me via the court system because he can. He knows I don't make as much money as him. He knows it's going to be hard for me to find a lawyer to represent me.

Judge Nesbitt: "Your perception of him harassing you I understand and respect it but that's your perception but trust me, he ain't harassing you."

Me: "But we've got all the court history to back it up."

Judge Nesbitt: "Trust me. You don't have a clue what can be done if that's all he wanted to do was harass you." -June 23, 2006

14. Me: "All these things that I haven't been able to read in defense of myself, can I submit these here & now and have something - put them in the record?"

Judge Nesbitt: "What are these things?"

Me: "This is my defense for myself against the allegations that she (Shelley Booker) makes in her report."

Judge Nesbitt: "....Do you have a copy?....How many pages is that -ish?....Let's do this. Michelle, would you grab this and shoot a copy......" -June 23, 2006

15. "They are not to discuss any aspect of anything involving litigation, custody, anything negative about either parent or anybody in anybody's household. I don't care if you live with a herd of gypsies or bikers, (Joseph)'s not going to say bad things about the bikers and vice-versa." -Judge Woody Nesbitt, June 23, 2006

16. Judge Nesbitt: "Do you have any questions at all right now?"

Me: "I wouldn't know what to ask."

Judge Nesbitt: "Ok. I want you to take a deep breath and I want you to know that everybody in this system is here to work with you..." - June 23, 2006

17. "Throughout this litigation, the Applicant (DBE) was given numerous times to exercise her rights. The problems with the hold up in the litigation was that the Applicant (DBE) would not cooperate with the court appointed (sic) mental health evaluator....Despite the court's request to place this matter back on the docket to resolve the pending issues, the Applicant (DBE) has taken no action since July 2007." -Ron Miciotto, April 15, 2008

18. The Court (Judge Nesbitt, et al) added to the Interim Order from the June 23, 2006, hearing, provisions that were not a part of the Court's June 23, 2006, rulings and which were not discussed in open court.

19. On September 29, 2006, the Court (Judge Nesbitt) signed an ex parte order based in part on the language added after the fact from the June 23, 2006, hearing entirely suspending my visitation with my son. The Court (Judge Nesbitt, et al) failed to timely rescind this order or set a hearing.

20. The Court (Judge Nesbitt, et al) refused to set a hearing after I formally requested one on December 12, 2006.

One last goof recorded nearly half-way through our 2006 custody hearing:
Ron Miciotto: "Your Honor, I may have missed this. Has she (DBE) been placed under oath?"
Judge Nesbitt: "I don't know....Let's oath everybody." -June 23, 2006

Former-Judge Woodrow "Woody" Nesbitt has since quit the bench, and gone into private practice with his dear friend, attorney Ron Miciotto.

32 comments:

. said...

and now....at what should be the end of this abuse of our legal system your opposition has managed to get the new judge to recuse....these snakes can protract this into oblivion. it's disgusting.

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Lisa Smith Sims: "You are such a strong woman I tell you just from reading this you have walked threw the fire. This will all be "Righted" by God someday. I don't know when and I don't know exactly how, but I do know God will "Right Over" everyone of Pete's "Wrongs" that he has done to you by using his position.
God Don't Like Ugly, and Ugly is exactly what someone ... Read Morehas been doing to you for a very long time.
I would be an emotional wreck after having gone through this time & time again, having so many people just steam roll right over you just simply because they could. You hang in there as only a Great Mom would and this will be one day taken care of by God. Sometimes that is all we really have to fall on is our Faith and knowing that there is nothing greater we can do but Trust in the Lord to see us through."
August 23 at 10:01am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Joanna Ballard Louisiana Storyteller: "Hugssssssssssssssssssssssssss ...You are a brave and strong woman and folks wonder why I have NO trust in our justice system!"
August 23 at 10:02am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Alana Dyson: "My GOD! I knew they were railroading you, but I don't think I've EVER read anything this utterly FUCKED UP in my entire life. TRAVESTY of JUSTICE (plus the pic at the end made me tear up). Those bastards need to eat shit, die, and go to hell."
August 23 at 12:01pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Alan Dyson: "well said alana.
these guys are abusing the system for personal gain and to do damage to the relationship between a mother and her son.
i cannot understand this complete lack of reason."
August 23 at 1:15pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Tony Reans: "Wow. My words are inadequate. The best I can say is that my heart goes out to you. Danielle and I are by your side if your strength or hope wavers. You can always pick up the phone, and we'll be right there."
August 23 at 1:52pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Steven Louis Soffer: "whilst I agree with ALL the comments above, personally they should get a one way trip to my beloved home towne of philly. stick em in a house call them move2 and bomb the fuckers back past the stone age!!They could always be slathered in honey and drop in the middle of marchng South American Army ants.just sayin...tho I might add that those in hell... Read More should not be sullied by these ass fuck red neck chicken fucking inbred scroudum licking jizz drentched rat fuck rat fink evangelical cracker shit ride their 200 foot limp cross till their balls pop out their ass lsu educated poprk rine eatting douche bastards.. if that doesnt adjust their attitute, then some philly street justice. believe you me bubbas aint got nothin on us when we are sticking up?for one of OUR family. It read like a really bad tennesee williamsplay. wheres boss hog? i will close with; let em join jimmy hoffa-well at least they could view a football game....ever consider trying for dateline?nightline/OPHRA?"
August 23 at 1:57pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Debbie Buchanan Engle: "Just promise that, if you ever see anything like this happening, you'll jump all off in the middle of it and work hard to make it right.

No kid should ever have to go thru this crap!!"
August 23 at 3:04pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Kathryn Usher: "Deb -- all this writing is confusing. You need a filmmaker to tell your story. I'm interested. Are you? A tiny film telling the story of an American mom who wants her child..."
August 24 at 12:44am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Alan Dyson: "i'd be in for that"
August 24 at 6:26am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Leland Strebeck: "it would have to be a comedy right? let's oath everybody??"
August 24 at 8:23am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Debbie Buchanan Engle: "Funny you should mention Mel Brooks...Judge Nesbitt is a lot like Dark Helmet in "SpaceBalls."

Ron Miciotto is like Joe Pesci in "Casino."

Stepmom is like every woman on "Desperate Housewives."...

And my ex taunts me like the French knight in Holy Grail.

We may be onto something here....Joseph's gonna love this!"
August 24 at 10:09am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Erin Echterhoff: "Debbie my heart breaks that you had to endure such stubborn and hostile behavior just to get to love your child- The court can be fair but the court with the correct trilogy of people can become the most evil place on earth .I do find extreme humor in all of the diialogue- but the part that sickens me was that it was at your exspense. How do ... Read Morepeople like Woody Nesbitt become the people that they are and how come the judege was so damn convinced that you were not a target in this matter it seemed quite evident - the comments about your temperment are hilarious basically you were pissed off. Mrs Booker in her experience could not note that?
She had made up her mind from the start and unfortunatley I know her and she doesn't play fair. Bless you for having to go thru that - But it is amazing you found joy and peace at times that is remarkable-love ya"
August 24 at 1:18pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Jessica Kaylor Morgan: "I finally stopped to read this, and WOW is about all I can say. You should submit some of this shit to The Tonight Show for their top 10 lists, and any other media outlet you can think of. Crikes!!! Makes me ill. Litterally, physically ILL!"
August 24 at 1:49pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Alan Dyson: "throughout this ordeal debbie has reacted as any person unjustly threatened with having their children taken away would.
in this case it was clear that the judge was in league with the opposition, and booker was a willing accomplice. she even announced to debbie during one of their "sessions" that she was going to help them take her son away. this ... Read Moreis the height of arrogance and a deliberate obstruction of justice.
i have been shocked to realize how completely our legal system can be manipulated.
as her case continues - the opposition is now resorting to tactics of delay and evasion. they can effectively protract this litigation indefinitely. they will no doubt continue challenging all findings they decide to not agree with and fabricate lies trying to cripple her financially, mentally, physically, and emotionally.
there was no justification for this in the beginning - there is no justification for it now. this behavior should be grounds for disbarment."
August 24 at 1:52pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Susan Breeland: "Debbie, I am so sorry, again, I just read only a portion of your notes!! Maybe I should have sued my parents for not having my orthodontic work done?? Thousands and thousands of dollars, that I could have had done as an adult myself......I also went through a small amount of what you are going through. I just wondered if my daughter could sue ... the judge when she came of age. I tried to hide my daughter, but found out I would be put in jail, so I had to do as the judge said, and live in fear of her safety. She now knows how to sell dope, and at the age of 10 saw someone beat up because they would not pay for it....I am still finding out things she wanted to protect me from and she is now 34 and physically ill to the point of disability, and her depression never seems to go away!!.......YES we need to fight these judges, and the attorneys that think we are "outragious" and "over reactive" Mothers....YES... they wanted to hospitalize me, uncontrolled anger!!! and FEAR!!"
August 24 at 3:30pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Susan Breeland: "Ran out of room on the first comment!! The judge nor the attorney (my own) will listen. I was told that if I had been in Bossier Parish, it would not have gone that way!!! I have seen the difference recently in Bossier Parish with my own daughter's divorce and support demanded for her by the court system (spousal support). The judges here are ... much better!! Oh, I better stop about Bossier Parish compared to Caddo!! Anyway, I will be praying for you and your family and you must know that our Lord IS in control. And know that He IS the "Great I Am"!! Debbie, HE is the ONLY
way you are going to make it through this. My Faith was not as strong then as it is now, and I don't know how I did it that way."
August 24 at 3:35pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Debbie Buchanan Engle: "S, I had no idea!

It seems like there would be a children's advocate program to help kids have a say-so in custody battles. Plus, therapy provided for them - paid for by the plaintiff!

Historically, women have been shunned as emotional, irrational and crazy. I totally expected that in a courtroom full of men - but certainly not to this degree....

Even AFTER I was thoroughly evaluated by 2 psychiatrists & a psychologist (still paying for that), my ex insists I am crazy. He tells Joseph he is "acting in his best interests" by keeping him away from me.

And Shelley Booker, who lives a few houses down the street from the Kammers, has kids who go to school with the younger Kammer children & she hangs out with stepmom & dad all the time! They've been friends for years!!

Joseph knew that going into this, but I didn't find out til later. He told me that, from the beginning, he knew exactly what Shelley Booker would do to me because she & Stacey are such good friends."
August 24 at 3:40pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Jessica Kaylor Morgan: "And this is why I moved to Texas! Seriously. The laws were SOOO much better, and I was fighting a hard battle myself. Distance and good legal system. Well, at least not as corrupt as Louisiana."
August 24 at 4:08pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Susan Breeland: "Yes, the some judges (in some parishes...get it!!) look at women as over reactive and exaggerating mothers...and I WAS a "nut job" out of fear!!! Afterward the Psychiatric Social Workers had to teach my daughter how to be an adult when she visited her father...maybe that is why she tried to protect me from the things he did or said while she ... visited with him....like the JUDGE said I was supposed to put her at 4 years of age on an airplane by herself to fly to his apartment in Houston???.......Sorry, but Judges in Caddo have a bbbiiiiggg problem (at least 30 years ago they did).
I was hoping it was better today."
August 24 at 4:20pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Susan Breeland: "One more comment!! sorry...I was thinking back some maybe 25 years ago, there was a mother arrested and put in prison for not letting her child see the father under a court order. It was a huge deal on the news, and the reporters kept up with her for quite a while. Before she went to prison, she made sure her daughter was hidden. I don't know if ... Read Moreshe was ever released, but the last I heard years ago her daughter was still not to be found....I can totally understand why she did this, and Debbie, I believe you would have sided with the mother too!!"
August 24 at 4:41pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Debbie Buchanan Engle: "They were going to put me in jail for not paying for half of Joseph's braces, contacts, and court costs (of course).

My sister loaned me $2600 to keep me out of jail."
August 24 at 6:45pm

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Erin Echterhoff: "It is difficult to comment because I am so shocked by the comments but I have seen thru counseling (former profession) what the court will do to the mother just because the dad has more monetary access and the judge the case is set before I know the family of the lady that hid her child and I used to wonder if she really could have done it another ... Read Moreway-----Hell no she did it out of sheer terror for her child. Debbie I will pray often for your peace I did not realize to what extent your soul had been dug into by this evil process. I love you for still being so funny and kind and an advocate for others the rest of the parties will pay one day in Hell. You will one day be given peace------God will grant you that."
Tue at 10:56am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Alan Dyson: "we did a therapeutic project called "judge not" during the first christmas holiday that debbie was denied contact with her son. it was a way to give her a chance to express herself where the judicial system, manipulated as it was, failed her. the imagery was strong and provocative. these could serve as a story board. and while the comedy potential in all of this is significant - we need to be sure the viciousness of this type of manipulation is made clear."
Wed at 8:35am

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

All the above comments are from supportive friends.

They wrote me via Facebook, and the total comments so far are up to 41!

Thank you, everybody - You have each been a Godsend to both Joseph and me! -Deb

Anonymous said...

LOL Ron is my attorney on retainer. I read your story and i have to say if you have several very intelligent people saying your nuts and you saying your arent well honey your probably nuts. Your only mad because you couldnt afford a kick ass attorney -Ron- and you got your ass kicked in the court system, obviously in your situation you are the problem and everyone sees that and is removing you from it. oh well sucks to be you. I suggest next time you raise a better child and do a better job being a good parent and good wife and you wouldnt piss people off so bad that they go to this extent to get you out of the picture. im sure your going to love to comment back on what your reading so leave me a voicemail. 318.517.0364

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

Dear Anon,

I appreciate your enlightened opinion on my 5-year custody battle. You truly sound like someone who would stoop to hiring Ron Miciotto as her attorney.

For the record, I won my case against my son's father in May, 2011. All reports against me were proven false, Mr. Miciotto was told by the court that he needed to stop presenting frivolous evidence against me, and my son told the judge that he wanted to come home.

I will not grant you the priviledge of speaking to me on the phone. You obviously have other, more pressing issues with which you should cope.

I wish you the best, and will be happy to refer you to my "kick-ass" attorney when you are broke after paying Ron Miciotto too much money for his incompetent services.

-Debbie Buchanan Engle

Debbie Buchanan Engle said...

One more thing, Tracy Bannett.

You're gonna need to wise up when you go to court.

Now everyone knows your phone number, name & address (10233 Locke Road, Keithville, LA).

I hope your nasty attitude toward victims of the corrupt Caddo Parish court system doesn't affect business at Blackwood Services.

You really should be more careful about who you verbally assault in a public forum.

Have a nice day. -Deb

Unknown said...

My sister had to deal with the same duo i believe, Nesbit and Miciotto. Would you mind posting YOUR attorneys info here? We are looking at 7 years of this custody battle so far.

Debbie Hollis said...

LC, even after i found an attorney who would represent me, it took several years to resolve this custody dispute...primarily because of the $$ connection between the judges, my ex, Miciotto and Nesbitt. A lot of money changes hands among those 3 guys and the judges in the 1st Judicial district. It's practically impossible to get an unbiased judgement - or an attorney to challenge their financial control of the courts - in Caddo/Bossier Parishes.

Basically, my son had to turn 18 before anything was really resolved. Even then, his lawyer-dad kept the final court order from ever being signed by the judge. To this day, there is no final judgement signed by the court after 16 years of litigation. These guys have so much control over our judges, they actually prevent them from signing their own orders into effect.

The attorney who represented me for the last 5 years is Curtis Shelton. He is in Shreveport, and you can find him via Google. regardless of what your tourney you choose, you will likely have the same outcome as me. There is no way around Miciotto, Nesbitt, and Kammer's financial control over the judges.

Anonymous said...

Debbie,
I think you are Strong and Brave. I have read your blog before and tried to contact you as I was reliving your story. Reading your blog one night was like looking through a crystal ball of the exact unjust I have been dealing with since 2011. Your words describe it perfect. Of course we both know there is more to the story! As you could have exposed alot more than your did. People who hire them have something to hide while the people who are the true victims and telling the truth never get heard in our system. Thank you for speaking up about the truth. Another fact are the players in Ron's court are the same still playing today. I hope someday this courtroom network is busted up and exposed.

Unknown said...

Amen to that on the last comment!! I totally agree the ones who hire rjm DO HIDE THINGS. while the victim sit back wonder what they did wrong and wondering how someone who been exposed/by proof by text and pics and much more and get away with it! I do wish and pray this is exposed nationally! And someone take it to higher level to where it's revealed. I'm praying to this day. God will expose this man and all his wrongdoings!